United States v. Terry J. Hatter, JR., Judge, United States District Court for the Central District of California, et al. (532 U.S. 557)
U.S. Supreme Court · decided May 21, 2001 · Supreme Court Database (Spaeth)
- Citation
- 532 U.S. 557 · 121 S. Ct. 1782
- Decided
- May 21, 2001
- Term
- October Term 2000
- Vote
- 5–2
- Majority author
- Justice Breyer
- Issue area
- Federal Taxation
- Disposition
- Affirmed and reversed (or vacated) in part and remanded
- Outcome
- Petitioning party won
- Ideological direction
- Liberal
- Constitutional ruling
- Federal law held unconstitutional
Opinion excerpt
Justice Breyer delivered the opinion of the Court. The Constitution’s Compensation Clause guarantees federal judges a “Compensation, which shall not be diminished during their Continuance in Office.” U. S. Const., Art. Ill, § 1. The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit held that this Clause prevents the Government from collecting certain Medicare and Social Security taxes from a small number of federal judges who held office nearly 20 years ago — before Congress extended the taxes to federal employees in the early 1980’s. In our view, the Clause does not prevent Congress from imposing a "non-diseriminatory tax laid generally” upon judges and other citizens, O’Malley v. Woodrough, 307 U.S. 277, 282 (1989), but it does prohibit taxation that singles out judges for specially unfavorable treatment. Consequently, unlike the Court of Appeals, we conclude that Congress may apply the Medicare tax — a nondiseriminatory tax — to then-sitting federal judges. The special retroactivity-related Social Security rules that Congress enacted in 1984, however, effectively singled out then-sitting federal judges for unfavorable treatment. Hence, like the Court of Appeals, we conclude that the Clause forbids the application of the Social Security tax to those judges. I A The Medicare law before us is straightforward. In 1965, Congress created a Federal Medicare “hospital insurance” program…
Excerpt of a 41,108-character opinion. The full text and citation network load in the interactive viewer above.